Spreadsheet, off-the-shelf or custom software?
Three ways to run your operations. None of them suits everyone. Here is how to choose, honestly, even when the answer is not us.
The spreadsheet
Excel, Google Sheets
Best when
- one or two people use it
- the way you work still changes often
- the data fits in a few tabs
Starts to pinch when
- several people edit the same file
- you need to know who changed what, and when
- versions multiply by email
Off-the-shelf software
A monthly subscription
Best when
- you work like most businesses in your field
- you want to start tomorrow
- the team using it is small
Starts to pinch when
- you still keep a spreadsheet on the side
- the subscription grows with every employee
- the feature, or the French, you need is missing
Custom software
Built for you
Best when
- your operations have quirks no software plans for
- several people work on the same data
- you want to own the tool
Starts to pinch when
- you need something next week
- the way you work is not settled yet
- existing software already does the job well
Side by side
To get started
- Spreadsheet:
- Next to nothing
- Off-the-shelf:
- A first month of subscription
- Custom:
- A project, paid once
Over time
- Spreadsheet:
- Your teams' time
- Off-the-shelf:
- A subscription that grows with the team
- Custom:
- Maintenance, if you want it
Getting going
- Spreadsheet:
- Immediate
- Off-the-shelf:
- Quick
- Custom:
- The time it takes to build
How you work
- Spreadsheet:
- As far as a file allows
- Off-the-shelf:
- You adapt to the software
- Custom:
- The tool adapts to you
Several people at once
- Spreadsheet:
- Risky
- Off-the-shelf:
- Yes
- Custom:
- Yes, each by role
Your data
- Spreadsheet:
- In scattered files
- Off-the-shelf:
- With the vendor
- Custom:
- In your database
In French
- Spreadsheet:
- Up to you
- Off-the-shelf:
- Up to the vendor
- Custom:
- From the first version
What you own
- Spreadsheet:
- The file
- Off-the-shelf:
- A licence to use it
- Custom:
- The source code
Signs it is time to change
- Two versions of the same file are going around, and nobody knows which is right.
- Only one person understands how the spreadsheet works.
- The same data is entered in two places.
- You pay for a subscription and still keep a spreadsheet on the side.
- The month's numbers arrive too late to decide anything.
Our honest take
If a spreadsheet is enough, keep it. If existing software fits how you work, take it. We build custom when neither does the job. And if, on the first call, existing software looks like a better fit for you, we will tell you.