Custom ERP or Odoo, Acomba, Sage?
There is no best ERP, only the one that fits your company. Here is when each option makes sense, including when custom does not.
The options at a glance
Starting point
- Custom ERP
- Your operations
- Configurable ERP (Odoo, Business Central)
- Modules to configure
- Management software (Acomba, Sage)
- Standard software
Price
- Custom ERP
- Fixed, paid once
- Configurable ERP (Odoo, Business Central)
- Implementation and monthly licences
- Management software (Acomba, Sage)
- Licence or subscription
Per user
- Custom ERP
- No fee
- Configurable ERP (Odoo, Business Central)
- Depends on the edition
- Management software (Acomba, Sage)
- Depends on the product
Adapting it
- Custom ERP
- Anything is possible
- Configurable ERP (Odoo, Business Central)
- By configuration, then development
- Management software (Acomba, Sage)
- Limited
Source code
- Custom ERP
- Handed to you
- Configurable ERP (Odoo, Business Central)
- Depends on edition and integrator
- Management software (Acomba, Sage)
- With the vendor
Getting started
- Custom ERP
- One part at a time
- Configurable ERP (Odoo, Business Central)
- Depends on the scope
- Management software (Acomba, Sage)
- Often fast
When to choose Acomba or Sage
If your main need is accounting and simple management, established software is often the right call. Your accountant knows these products. They tend to pinch when your operations (production, job sites, steps unique to your trade) do not fit their screens.
When to choose Odoo or Business Central
If how you work resembles your industry's norm and you are ready to adapt some of it, a configurable ERP offers a lot, quickly. Look at the total cost: implementation, licences year after year, and the price of every adaptation and every upgrade. Choose your integrator carefully too, since it matters as much as the software.
When to choose custom
- How you work is what sets you apart.
- The software you tried left you with spreadsheets on the side.
- Per-user licences weigh more and more.
- You want to own your system rather than rent it.
Six questions to ask before signing
- What is the total cost over five years, licences and maintenance included?
- What costs more when we add an employee?
- Who owns the code and the data?
- How is our existing data moved over?
- Is the whole tool in French, as Law 96 requires?
- What happens if we change vendors?
Frequently asked questions
What is the best ERP for a Quebec SMB?
It depends on your operations. For simple accounting and management, Acomba or Sage often fit. For standard processes, Odoo or Business Central are solid. When how you work does not fit that software, a custom ERP starts to make sense.
Is a custom ERP more expensive than Odoo?
At first, often yes. Over several years, compare the total cost: a custom ERP has no per-user licence, while a configurable ERP adds licences and adaptation fees. The right answer depends on your team's size and what needs adapting.
Can we start small?
Yes. We build the part that hurts most first, then add the others on the same data, each at a fixed price.